Preloop vs Lunar.dev MCPX: Human approvals in the free core
Preloop is the open-source AI agent control plane: an MCP firewall, AI model gateway, human-in-the-loop approvals, runtime observability, and a hash-chained audit trail in one self-hostable Apache 2.0 platform. Lunar.dev sells MCPX, an MCP gateway with an AI gateway and agent governance, licensed per seat with a free tier and an MIT-licensed open source project. The honest one-liner: both are self-hosted MCP gateways; choose Preloop when you want approvals, audit, and the model gateway in the open-source core rather than in a paid tier.
At a glance
| Feature | Preloop | Lunar.dev MCPX |
|---|---|---|
| License | Apache 2.0 (open source core) | Open core: MIT open source project plus paid tiers, "licensed per seat" |
| Self-hosted option | Yes, Docker or Kubernetes | Yes: "Fully self-hosted"; Enterprise runs on "self-hosted Kubernetes" |
| Plans | Open source free; Cloud and Enterprise plans | Free (up to 50 users), Pro (up to 100 users), Enterprise (custom) |
| Human-in-the-loop approvals | Yes, per tool call, in the open-source core | "HITL: Human Approval Workflows" is listed in the plan comparison |
| MCP firewall | Yes: allow / deny / require-approval / require-justification on arguments | Yes: MCP gateway with registry, identity, roles, and isolation (pricing) |
| Model gateway with budgets | Yes, in the open-source core: OpenAI-, Anthropic- and Gemini-compatible, per-agent attribution | Yes: "AI Gateway: route, budget, and observe LLM traffic" |
| Audit / evidence | Hash chain with signed checkpoints, in the open-source core | "Full audit trails" described as part of the Enterprise version |
| Policy-as-code | Yes: YAML plus CEL on tool arguments | Gateway policy, tool parameter pinning, intent-based tool usage (pricing) |
| Onboards existing local agents | Yes: preloop agents discover and preloop agents onboard |
No direct equivalent found |
| Works with any agent runtime | Claude Code, Codex CLI, Cursor, Gemini CLI, OpenClaw, OpenCode, Hermes, any MCP client | MCP clients and LLM apps through its gateways |
What Lunar.dev MCPX does well
Lunar.dev is a serious MCP gateway vendor, and its product has grown past "MCP proxy":
- Open-source starting point. The free version "is a fully functional open-source MCP gateway you can run locally or with your team" (Lunar pricing FAQ), so you can evaluate it without a sales call.
- Self-hosted by design. Enterprise deployments run on your own infrastructure, "so data never leaves your environment" (pricing FAQ).
- Breadth. The plan comparison lists agent inventory and identity, hosted MCP, secrets integration with Vault, shadow MCP detection, anomaly detection, and an AI gateway with token budgets (pricing).
- Enterprise identity. SSO and RBAC through your identity provider, a private MCP registry, and a risk dashboard in the Enterprise version.
If you want a per-seat, self-hosted MCP gateway with a broad enterprise feature list, Lunar.dev is a credible option.
Where Preloop is different
Preloop and Lunar.dev both sit in front of MCP tool calls. The differences are where the open-core line sits and what the agent side looks like.
- Approvals, audit, and gateway in the open-source core. Per-call approvals, the model gateway with budgets, the MCP firewall, session observability, and the hash-chained audit trail all ship in Apache 2.0. What Preloop sells is the organizational layer: multiple approvers, quorum, escalations, users, teams, and RBAC.
- No seat count. The open-source core has no user tiers. Lunar's plans are defined by user counts (pricing).
- Native agent actions, not only MCP. With
--approvals, Preloop installs native action gates for Claude Code, Codex CLI, Cursor, Copilot CLI, OpenCode, and others, so shell commands and file edits can wait for the same approval as an MCP call. - Approvals people answer. Reviewers get the tool, arguments, agent reasoning, and matched policy on mobile, Apple Watch, Slack, Mattermost, email, webhook, or the CLI.
- Onboarding.
preloop agents discoverfinds local agent configurations;preloop agents onboardroutes supported agents through Preloop, with backups and a dry-run preview. - Policy-as-code with CEL. Ordered YAML rules with CEL conditions evaluate tool arguments and version-control with the rest of your infrastructure.
When to choose Lunar.dev MCPX
- You want a per-seat, self-hosted MCP gateway and Kubernetes is your standard platform.
- You need features on Lunar's list that Preloop does not ship, such as shadow MCP detection or Vault secrets integration.
- Your scope is mainly MCP access management for employees and agents.
When to choose Preloop
- Platform and DevEx teams that want human approvals and policy enforcement in the open-source core.
- Teams rolling out coding agents (Claude Code, Codex CLI, Cursor, Gemini CLI, OpenClaw, OpenCode) who need native action gates as well as MCP governance.
- Security teams that need a self-hostable control plane with searchable, hash-chained audit evidence inside their own network.
- Teams building EU AI Act readiness evidence that need durable records of matched policy, approver, justification, and outcome.
FAQ
Is there an open-source MCP gateway with approvals in the free core? Yes. Preloop is Apache 2.0 and ships per-call human approvals in the open-source core, alongside the MCP firewall, AI model gateway, runtime observability, and audit trail.
Does Lunar.dev have human approvals? Its plan comparison lists "HITL: Human Approval Workflows". Check with Lunar.dev which tier includes them for your user count; the public page shows the features per plan as icons.
Can I self-host Preloop without Kubernetes? Yes. Preloop runs from Docker for a single-node setup and on Kubernetes when you need it.
Does Preloop cover model traffic as well as MCP? Yes. The model gateway has budgets and per-agent, per-flow, and per-key attribution, so tool calls and model spend are governed in one product.
How do I onboard existing agents to Preloop?
Run preloop agents discover to find local agent configurations, then preloop agents onboard to route the supported ones through Preloop.
Try Preloop
Last reviewed: 2026-10-08.